Although the Observation of the Week, changes each week, it doesn't seem fast enough. I post the OOTW each Sunday/Monday, but as I log into iNaturalist each successive day to see what is being observed and to try to glean the best image/observation for the following week (the OOTW is always from the previous Sunday-Saturday), I find that there are a plethora of new observations that could have been the OOTW for the previous week, but will be eclipsed by even newer observations by Saturday or Sunday (when the final decision is made).
So, although some observations (many of my own, because they are out of focus) have pictures that will not rate OOTW, many more just occur at the wrong time. Unless they stand out significantly, the newer observations tend to take the prize, so to speak.
The other problem I have encountered is scale. Sometimes the photos, which are mostly taken on a smartphone, do not scale well for the size of the image we would like. For instance, The image size for the project page banner is 760x320 pixels, the social media pages generally take a square image, while most of the original images are neither.
The Observation of the Month is posted as the NYMS collection group’s banner (https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/nyms), on the society’s twitter page (https://twitter.com/newyorkmyc), and on our instagram feed (https://www.instagram.com/newyorkmyc/). Every observation is carefully attributed to the photographer who took the photo used (with their permission).
The following are the criteria used for selection of the OOTM:
- Observation must have at least one photo associated with it
-
PHOTOGRAPH MUST BE IN FOCUS (especially when blown up)
- Observation must fall under the myxomycetes/slime molds or Fungi Kingdom.
- The observer must be a member, in good standing, of the New York Mycological Society
- Observation must be added to one of the two official NYMS iNaturalist projects
- Fungi of NYC - https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/fungi-of-nyc-new-york-mycological-society
- Fungi Beyond NYC - https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/fungi-beyond-nyc-new-york-mycological-society (Please note the location parameters on the about section of this project)
The observation must be made in the coverage area indicated on one of the two project pages listed above
Observation should be identified to, at least, the genus level, by a reliable source
Observations that are of particular interest, vis-a-vis specimens that are of interest from a scientific or conservation perspective, will be given preference
Prefer photos that can be cropped to 760x320, squared, etc. – so some surroundings in the frame is best
The most recent observations take precedence if all other criteria have been met.
The following criteria are used post-selection:
- The observer must give their permission to use said observation, with proper attribution, before the OOTW is posted (unless they have already given permission to use photos via the form).
- The observer will be credited with the photo observation with text indicating all social media accounts we have on file for them and/or a “Photo by …” text.
- The selected image may be cropped to fit the various formats.
You can read about the process of choosing the OOTM here